|
|
||||||||
|
J Am Dent Assoc, Vol 131, No 12, 1721-1728.
© 2000 American Dental Association |
SPECIAL REPORT |
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Conclusions. "Oral Health in America" identifies opportunities for the dental profession on behalf of the nations overall health. The profession is uniquely positioned to ensure that all components of the National Oral Health Plan are addressed: changing perceptions to ensure that oral health is seen as integral to general health; removing barriers to care; enhancing health infrastructure; accelerating the transfer of science into practice; and continuing to participate in private/public partnerships.
Clinical Implications. The reports findings highlight the importance of assessing patients known risks of experiencing oral diseases and of educating patients about health-promoting behaviors. The integral role of oral health in general health, as described in the report, makes it imperative for health professionals to ensure appropriate referrals to practitioners in all areas of health care.
The relationship between dentist and patient is personal, private and productive. Thus, it was no surprise when we were told that U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Donna Shalalas personal dentist stimulated her interest in commissioning the first surgeon generals report on oral health in April 1997. The charge for this report was to "define, describe, and evaluate the interaction between oral health and general health and well-being [quality of life] through the life span in the context of changes in society." In May, the report, called "Oral Health in America: A Report of the Surgeon General," was released by U.S. Surgeon General David Satcher.1 As the first such report for the United States, it provides the dental profession with an unprecedented opportunity to demonstrate its continued leadership on behalf of the nations health.
A report issued by the U.S. surgeon general is a rare and special event. During the past 46 years, the surgeon generals reports have focused primarily on the health consequences of smoking and tobacco-use practices. The nontobacco-related reports are relatively few in number and tend to focus on other lifestyle behaviors. These reports are intended to focus the nations attention on important emerging public health issuesparticularly those that require unusual and immediate interventions, those that affect a large proportion of the public, and those in which important new advances have been made or where the opportunity to further improve the nations health has not been fully realized. In this category are reports on topics such as AIDS, mental health, maternal and child health, and oral health.
The report highlights the substantial gains in the oral health status of the American population over the past 50 years. However, it also points out that not all segments of the population have participated in these gains. The reasons for this are many; inadequate access to care and inaccurate public perceptions of oral health are two of the foremost.
The reports major, and overriding, themes convey the messages that oral health means much more than healthy teeth and that oral health is integral to general health.
Here we will review the reports statements in response to each of these questions.
What is oral health?
How many of us take the time to inform our patients of the wealth of functions and conditions affecting our mouths and other craniofacial structures that, in turn, affect our overall health? The surgeon generals report emphasizes the broad definition of oral health, stating that it includes all aspects of the dental, oral and craniofacial complex. The report provides a detailed reminder of the interaction, interconnectedness and inseparable aspects of oral and general health. It also reminds the reports readers that our oral-facial tissues have functions that we often take for granted, even though "they represent the very essence of our humanity. They allow us to speak and smile; sigh and kiss; smell, taste, touch, chew, and swallow; cry out in pain; and convey a world of feelings and emotions through facial expressions."1
The report describes the development, genetics and functions of the oral-facial tissues from birth to old age. For even the most academically prepared reader, such an overview is a refresher. The report informs readers that some of these tissues are unique in the body; others are part of systems such as the mucosal and skeletal systems. It also highlights the intricate functions that saliva and the salivary glands perform in protecting against pathogens and promoting digestion and other functions.
What is the status of oral health in America?
The report addresses the extent of selected major oral and cranio-facial diseases and disorders, as well as the complex and multi-factorial nature of their etiology and pathogenesis. It also describes the current understanding of a multitude of oral microbial infections, such as dental caries, periodontal diseases, herpes labialis and candidiasis. The rapidly evolving knowledge of the genetic aspects of oral conditions and of the role of microbes and risk factors provides dental practitioners with an opportunity for earlier diagnosis and increasingly nonsurgical management. The report emphasizes that lifestyle behaviors such as use of tobacco and alcohol and inappropriate diet pose risks for general health, including oral health. In this context, the challenges for oral health care providers are to determine to what extent our health education messages for patients are directed at these known risk factors, and how we can be more effective in changing behaviors that put our patients at risk.
There have been many gains in the nations oral health in the last half-century, but challenges remain. For example, there has been a substantial decline in edentulism over the past 20 years2,3 (Figure 1
![]()
MESSAGES AND ACTIONS
TOP
ABSTRACT
MESSAGES AND ACTIONS
FIVE KEY QUESTIONS: WHAT...
A FRAMEWORK FOR ACTION
THE REPORT AS A...
CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
For those in the dental profession, many of the messages of "Oral Health in America" are not new. Nevertheless, for the public and for the health care provider community at large, this report presents bold messages about the importance of oral health and what can be done to further improve itand, thereby, improve general healthin this country. The reports major message is that "oral health is essential to the general health and well-being of all Americans and that improved oral health can be achieved by all Americans."1
![]()
FIVE KEY QUESTIONS: WHAT THE REPORT ADDRESSES
TOP
ABSTRACT
MESSAGES AND ACTIONS
FIVE KEY QUESTIONS: WHAT...
A FRAMEWORK FOR ACTION
THE REPORT AS A...
CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
The current and future challenges to the public, providers of oral health services, educators, researchers, administrators and policy-makers are found in the responses to the five questions that serve as the framework of the surgeon generals report:
). Yet, dental caries remains one of the most common diseases of childhood3 (Figure 2
). Striking health disparities found for some populations include the five-year relative survival rate for oral and pharyngeal cancer4 (Figure 3
) and the prevalence of cleft lip and palate5 (Figure 4
) that differ between white and African-American people. The numbers of untreated decayed teeth in poor people and non-poor people also show disparities3 (Figure 5
). Finally, the report reveals that the common symptom of pain is a sequela of many conditions affecting oral health, reducing quality of life and restricting daily functions.
|
|
|
|
|
The rapidly evolving knowledge of the genetic aspects of oral conditions and of the role of microbes and risk factors provides dental practitioners with an opportunity for earlier diagnosis and increasingly nonsurgical management.
The reports examination of trends in dental care visits explains some of the variations seen in oral health status, but more studies need to be done. Detailed data on the magnitude of oral, dental and craniofacial health are lacking. Data are not readily available to provide an accurate picture of specific racial and ethnic population groups and people with special needs. Such data would facilitate local, state and national efforts to design programs tailored to such populations. Given the racial, ethnic and age projections for the United States population in the coming decades, we can expect further changes in the nations oral disease profile. We also can expect increasing numbers of patients frequenting our practices who have complex health conditions and are taking multiple medications.
What is the relationship between oral health and general health and well-being? The answers to this question address the centerpiece of the reports charge. Oral health and general health are linked inextricably. The mouth reflects general health or disease status, and oral cells, tissues and fluids increasingly are being used as diagnostic tools. As dentists, we know that what we see in the mouth is a reflection of a patients overall health, medications, harmful habits and nutritional status. The report makes it clear that numerous systemic diseases and conditions, as well as many pharmaceutical therapies, have oral manifestations.
In addition, the report applies criteria for assessing the quality of the published scientific evidence regarding associations between oral health and conditions and events such as diabetes, heart disease, stroke and adverse pregnancy outcomes. Further research is needed to determine whether these associations are causal or coincidental. These emerging findings should stimulate dentistry to consider how to maximize the delivery, referral and coordination of health care services with other health care providers so that patients benefit fully from evolving diagnostics and improved understanding of associations between oral health and other health conditions.
This portion of the report also demonstrates the relationship between oral health and quality of life. Oral health affects speech, eating, self-esteem, social interaction, education, career development and emotional state. The report notes that oral health clearly is related to well-being and quality of life when measured in functional, psychological and economic dimensions. Diet, nutrition, sleep and work all are affected by oral health status, and the overall societal burden that results from poor oral health is significant.
How is oral health promoted and maintained and how are oral diseases prevented? We in dentistry are fortunate to have an effective oral disease prevention and health promotion armamentarium for use by patients, dentists, other health care providers and communities in general. This is not the case for many other diseases that affect our population. The report emphasizes the importance of community water fluoridation as an effective, safe and ideal public health measure that benefits all people regardless of age or economic stratum. It acknowledges, however, that most of the available preventive approaches are focused on dental caries and periodontal diseases and that further research is needed to develop measures to prevent other oral diseases and conditions.
Both the patient and the health care provider, particularly the dentist, play specific, critical roles in perpetuating oral health. For members of the public, as well as for health care providers not in dentistry, this interconnected web of responsibilities and roles is news. Of particular interest to dental care providers is the promise of risk assessment methods and new diagnostic tests that can be applied with individual patients. In addition, the report acknowledges the development of evidence-based care and clinical practice guidelines stimulated by the health professions. This development is predicated on systematic searches of the scientific literature and the application of standard review methods in a manner that minimizes bias. One can envision that all health professions eventually will have guidelines based on systematic reviews as an aid to clinical decision making. Patients and their needs always will serve as our ultimate guide.
The report describes the uniqueand sometimes overlappingcontributions of the dental, medical and public health components of professional provision of oral health care. Some dentists, such as those who participate in lifestyle behavior modification programs, are involved in all three components. Estimates of national expenditures for dental health care and financing and reimbursement mechanisms demonstrate that Americans do invest substantially in oral health care services, the costs of which totaled an estimated $60 billion in 2000.6 However, this estimate does not include the many services rendered by other health care providers. The report also explores factors that affect the nations capacity to improve oral health, such as the need for adding oral health to curricula for all health professions, the need for additional faculty members in dental schools and the need for the dental work force to reflect the racial/ethnic and gender demographics of the U.S. population.
What are the needs and opportunities to enhance oral health? Determinants of health affect members of society across all life stages. The report discusses how a complex interplay of factorsindividual biology, physical and socioeconomic environment, personal behaviors and lifestyles, organization of health care servicesbears on the level of oral health a person achieves throughout life. Dental professionals can be even more effective in their contribution to improvements in the oral health of Americans, particularly children, elderly people and people with disabilities. The report notes that access to care makes a difference in oral health status and that barriers to that access must be reduced and eliminated. This requires an informed public and knowledgeable policy-makers, integrated and culturally competent programs of care, and the resources to pay and reimburse for care.
The report notes that many factors need to be addressed to increase access to care. Although the availability of insurance increases that access, there are 108 million Ameri-scans who do not have any form of dental insurance coverage. For every person without medical insurance, there are 2.7 people without dental insurance in this country.7 Federal and state assistance programs for selected oral health services exist, but they are limited in scope; furthermore, their reimbursement levels are low in comparison with the usual fees for care. Surely, reduction of these forms of barriers to care would have a profound effect on the numbers of people in a position to obtain needed dental care. In addition, the promise of science in creating new technologies for prevention, treatment, restoration and rehabilitation of oral and craniofacial disorders and conditions also may increase access to care.
The major findings of the report (see box
, "Major Findings of Oral Health in America: A Report of the Surgeon General ") send out resounding messages to patients, practitioners, program administrators and others concerned with the nations health.
|
| A FRAMEWORK FOR ACTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key components of this oral health plan require the continuation and expansion of public/private partnerships to improve the oral health of those who still suffer disproportionately from oral diseases, as well as to maintain the momentum of the gains already seen. In addition, components of the plan are needed to do the following:
| THE REPORT AS A SPRINGBOARD |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the press release, Secretary Shalala stated that the surgeon generals report on oral health "provides important reminders that oral health means more than sound teeth. Oral health is integral to overall health. Furthermore, safe and effective disease prevention measures exist that everyone can adopt to improve oral health and prevent disease. ... To ignore oral health problems can lead to needless pain and suffering, complications that can devastate well-being, and financial and social costs that significantly diminish quality of life and burden American society."8
Surgeon General Satcher stated in the press release that "serious oral disorders may undermine self-image and self-esteem, discourage normal social interaction, and lead to chronic stress and depression as well as incurring great financial cost. They may also interfere with vital functions such as breathing, eating, swallowing and speaking. The burden of disease restricts activities in school, work, and home, and often significantly diminishes the quality of life."8
The major messages of the report are well-known by the dental profession. However, this is the first time that a national leader has given such widespread visibility to the myriad of issues surrounding oral health. The dental profession can provide national leadership in changing the perceptions of the public, policy-makers and other health care providers about oral health and disease. As dental professionals, we can make sure that oral health is accepted as a critical component of general health. The reports findings provide the dental profession with the opportunity to inform and educate patients, other health care providers, the community and professional organizations of the existing methods we all can implement to promote and perpetuate our oral, dental and craniofacial health from childhood to old age. We need to inform others of the work that has been done and is under way. Dentistry has a proud tradition of preventing dental caries and periodontal disease, tobacco use and sports injuries, among others. But not everyone is familiar with these efforts. It is time that this story is told to those who may not be aware of itand the best tellers of any story are those who have lived it.
The report gives the dental profession a "heads-up" in preparing for the challenges of a rapidly changing patient pool. The projected trends in the nations demographics will present us with a different landscape of diseases and an older patient profile. As the knowledge base for oral health continues to evolve, the dental profession faces the need to stay informed, as well as to critically evaluate emerging technologies and ensure their timely incorporation into practice. The extensive array of conditions that affect the oral, dental and craniofacial complex also provides a challenge to all health care providers. Patients with conditions such as oral cancer, Sjögrens syndrome and cleft lip and/or palate require care from a multidisciplinary team of health care providers. Dental professionals need to ensure that they participate in patients overall care regardless of patients care setting, patients route of entry into care or the reimbursement for services.
Finally, the dental profession must take the lead in ensuring that the countrys health infrastructure is robust enough to meet projected oral health needs. We must recruit a diverse dental practice work force and take steps to ensure the expertise needed in dental school education, research and public health practice.
| CONCLUSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. E. Sanders, S. Lim, and W. Sohn Resilience to Urban Poverty: Theoretical and Empirical Considerations for Population Health Am J Public Health, June 1, 2008; 98(6): 1101 - 1106. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. S. Richards and M. R. Inglehart An interdisciplinary approach to case-based teaching: does it create patient-centered and culturally sensitive providers? J Dent Educ., March 1, 2006; 70(3): 284 - 291. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. M. Brown, D. Canham, and V. Y. Cureton An Oral Health Education Program for Latino Immigrant Parents The Journal of School Nursing, October 1, 2005; 21(5): 266 - 271. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |